The Hindu American Foundation Monday said they do not work as the spokesperson of any Indian government or any political party, reacting to MP Shashi Tharoor's allegation that the Indian-American community remained largely silent or absent as the US and India are caught in a quandary over several conflicting issues like tariffs and H-1B visas.
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor recently met a delegation of Indian-American politicians in India and claimed that one of them told Tharoor that her office did not get any call from any Indian-American voter asking her to raise the issue with India.
The silence of the Indian-origin tech CEOs has also come under scrutiny as they use the H-1B visa programs the most and now that the Donald Trump administration raised the H-1B visa fee to $100,000, these companies will have to pay the fee if they want to hire Indians or skilled people from any other countries.
Tharoor's accusation triggered a debate with many Indian-Americans commenting that their situation is difficult as they are often considered as 'foreign agents' in India and 'deportable' in the US.
"As American citizens of Indian origin we are indeed in a unique position to provide nuance to often one-dimensional narratives about India and Indians. We help elected leaders understand ground realities in India and dispel disinformation, not as mouthpieces for any Indian government or political party, but as Americans who straddle both cultures and are engaged in the democratic processes of our own country. And we do," the Hindu American Foundation said.
Tharoor replied to the pushback and said he's happy that his questions got the diaspora thinking. "Their challenges are indeed different from those of Jewish-Americans and Cuban-Americans, the examples I cited in my piece. But that doesn’t mean that within the rules of US democracy, they can’t make their voices heard — as these other groups so effectively do!" he said.
Earlier, HAF director Suhag A Shukla reacted to Tharoo's allegation and said the Indian government should not expect the diaspora to become their lobbyist. "The Govt of India does not ask our approval for its oil policy or import duties, and so
@shashitharoor and the GOI shouldn't be expecting us to champion their sovereign policy decisions with the U.S. government. They can hire lobbyists for that," she said.
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor recently met a delegation of Indian-American politicians in India and claimed that one of them told Tharoor that her office did not get any call from any Indian-American voter asking her to raise the issue with India.
The silence of the Indian-origin tech CEOs has also come under scrutiny as they use the H-1B visa programs the most and now that the Donald Trump administration raised the H-1B visa fee to $100,000, these companies will have to pay the fee if they want to hire Indians or skilled people from any other countries.
As American citizens of Indian origin we are indeed in a unique position to provide nuance to often one-dimensional narratives about India and Indians. We help elected leaders understand ground realities in India and dispel disinformation, not as mouthpieces for any Indian… https://t.co/s1uO0fwEmS
— Hindu American Foundation (@HinduAmerican) October 6, 2025
Tharoor's accusation triggered a debate with many Indian-Americans commenting that their situation is difficult as they are often considered as 'foreign agents' in India and 'deportable' in the US.
"As American citizens of Indian origin we are indeed in a unique position to provide nuance to often one-dimensional narratives about India and Indians. We help elected leaders understand ground realities in India and dispel disinformation, not as mouthpieces for any Indian government or political party, but as Americans who straddle both cultures and are engaged in the democratic processes of our own country. And we do," the Hindu American Foundation said.
I welcome the pushback from @SuhagAShukla (& there’s another one coming from @vivekwadhwa in tomorrow’s @IndianExpress). If my questions about the silence of the diaspora have got Indian-Americans thinking, I am happy. Their challenges are indeed different from those of… https://t.co/RPRNPb3uLz
— Shashi Tharoor (@ShashiTharoor) October 6, 2025
Tharoor replied to the pushback and said he's happy that his questions got the diaspora thinking. "Their challenges are indeed different from those of Jewish-Americans and Cuban-Americans, the examples I cited in my piece. But that doesn’t mean that within the rules of US democracy, they can’t make their voices heard — as these other groups so effectively do!" he said.
Earlier, HAF director Suhag A Shukla reacted to Tharoo's allegation and said the Indian government should not expect the diaspora to become their lobbyist. "The Govt of India does not ask our approval for its oil policy or import duties, and so
@shashitharoor and the GOI shouldn't be expecting us to champion their sovereign policy decisions with the U.S. government. They can hire lobbyists for that," she said.
You may also like
Vote for children's future; aim to make Bihar among top 10 in a decade: Prashant Kishor
Victim's clever move led cops to gang suspected of sending 40,000 stolen UK phones to China
BJP, Congress leaders condemn attack on CJI BR Gavai; call it an assault on judiciary and Constitution
Attack on CJI Gavai: Political leaders unite in condemnation; PM Modi terms act as 'reprehensible'
ITV Frauds viewers say 'I want it to be wrong' as they predict major twist
